((FnFS is hosted by Amy!))
This week’s question:
The very concept of Christian fiction had a huge battle to face in conservative circles and is, in my opinion, still facing those battles in its attempts to grow. Is there any value in reading fiction for Christians? Why are some people so resistant to the idea of reading fiction? If you DON’T read fiction, why don’t you read it? (Please keep in mind we are talking about ALL fiction and not just Christian fiction)
I don’t read a ton of fiction, but I do read some. I’m not against it. I guess I read more NONfiction because I love to learn, and I soak up knowledge like a sponge.
It used to be that I had a hard time reading Christian fiction. It was so preachy, and reminded me too much of the legalism in my family/church life. The preachiness of the books made me want to throw them across the room! Blessedly, the market has gotten a lot better, these days, and the books are getting more realistic. The characters aren’t all “perfect”, and there isn’t as much preachiness to the stories.
As for regular fiction, I don’t know why I don’t reach for it more often. I think I read about 75% nonfiction, and 25% fiction. When I do read fiction, the genre varies. I used to choose a lot of mystery/suspense, and the occasional light romance, but now I tend to choose romantic suspense, or fantasy — of all things! LOL. (I’m loving books about vampires and faeries!) LOL. I guess I still choose mystery/suspense, too, though, judging by the review books I’ve picked in the recent past.
If I had to guess, I’d say that I think a lot of people are resistant to reading fiction because (1) it may have too much in it that makes them think about their own lives, and maybe they don’t want to go there, (2) maybe they’re looking for something in a book, and they just aren’t finding it in fiction, and (3) maybe they hate it when a character’s life seems too “perfect” compared to their own. Honestly? I don’t know why people wouldn’t like fiction… I don’t even have a good reason for why I avoid it most of the time, myself! LOL.
As for the value Christians could get from reading fiction… I think Amy was right on when she said that reading fiction helps us connect to other people, and relate or find that we’re not alone. It can encourage us to keep on plugging — or that there’s hope. And, it can definitely still teach us things!
I still wholeheartedly believe that God can use even secular fiction to teach us… to speak to our hearts.
I’ve been learning, in my current ladies’ Bible study — “One in a Million” by Priscilla Shirer — though, that we also need to be careful in what we read. We have to watch that we don’t read anything that is going to distract us from God and His purposes for our lives. We have to stay away from the kind of reading that brings about the wrong responses in us. If it causes us to think impurely, or to become disastisfied with our lives, then it shouldn’t be something we’re reading.
Just last night, I was looking through a book in my collection called “Technical Virgin” by Hayley DiMarco, and in it she said that we need to be careful about reading romances, as they tend to make us have unrealistic expectations for our lives, and if we’re not careful, they can cause us to sin in that we become dissatisfied with our current situation.
Of course, I’m guilty of all of this. I’ve read a lot of books that I probably shouldn’t have. But, I’m slowly learning to be more discerning in my reading choices. I think I’ve become really desensitized to the danger of certain books, but this Bible study is reopening my eyes to the ways I’ve let myself slip.
Anyhoo. I’ve also had some really great fiction reading experiences. In 2002, I read a ton of fiction, both Christian and secular, and I still look back on that year fondly. There were a lot of books that really stuck with me. Sometimes it makes me think that I really should read more fiction than I do. In fact, I even joined a couple of reading challenges, this year, to help me with that goal — to get me to read more fiction. For example, the 12×12 challenge: It goes for one month at a time, each month being hosted by a different blogger. And, the goal is just to read more fiction. This month (February), J.Kaye is hosting.