Musing Mondays (Jan.17)
Do you prefer deep, intellectual, “meaty” books… or light, “fluffy” books? Why? Give us an example of your preferred type of book.
![]()
Most of the time, I think I prefer books that are somewhere in between. I don’t like my books too fluffy — I really don’t care for “chick lit” and the like. But, I don’t like them too intellectual or “meaty”, either, as then they just go right over my head!
For example, I read a book, last year, called “On Guard” by William Lane Craig. It’s a book on Apologetics, so I knew it would be a heavy read. But, little did I know that it would be so heavy! LOL. It really, honestly made my brain hurt, and I had to keep stopping and setting the book aside for a while, as I just couldn’t take any more! LOL.
But, then there are books like “Lost Christianities” by Bart D. Ehrman. This one was about the history of the Bible, and how the books that it contains came to be included, and why certain books were left out. I normally hate history, but this book was really interesting, and written in a way that it kept my attention.
For an example of what I do like, there’s “Deep in the Valley” by Robyn Carr… a little on the lighter side, but still with enough to it that I didn’t find it entirely fluffy; or “Everything’s Coming Up Josey” by Susan May Warren (still light, but not fluffy); or “Losing the Moon” by Patti Callahan Henry (somewhere in the middle); or “Mindless Eating” by Brian Wansink (getting meatier); or “Reading Lolita in Tehran” by Azar Nafisi (definitely more on the “meaty” side, but not so much that I disliked the book).
PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT with either the link to your own Musing Mondays post, or share your answers in a comment here (if you don’t have a blog). Thanks!












My answer was similar to yours. http://bfaos.blogspot.com/2011/01/monday-memes.html
Here’s mine…
http://addlife21.blogspot.com/2011/01/meaty-or-fluffy.html
A bright and early musing this week, neither too meaty nor too fluffy, right HERE
Interesting question…. I think they are actually getting better.
Here is my Musing for Monday.
Here’s my Musing Mondays.
I have done mine for the first time.
http://leetidsreading.blogspot.com/2011/01/musings-monday.html
http://readbookswritepoetry.blogspot.com/2011/01/mondays-mailboxwhat-are-you.html
Hi there!
Great question – here is my answer and my favourite choice of book…
http://bit.ly/gIrSQQ (A short and safe link)
Happy Monday!
heres mine i seem to have different answers to everyone else!
http://shelovesreading.wordpress.com/2011/01/17/musing-mondays-17th-jan/
Here’s mine! so glad to see Musing Mondays back!
http://www.bostonbibliophile.com/2011/01/musing-mondays-light-or-heavy.html
WOW, you really do like your deep reading, my reading preferences are here: http://annsreadingcorner.blogspot.com
http://dementedreading.blogspot.com/2011/01/this-weeks-musing-asks-do-you-prefer.html
My MM is here
See my post at raesamm.blogspot.com.
Here is mine
LOVE the musing this week very thought provoking.
Here is my Monday Musing.
Yea for Monday Musings! http://smashattackreads.blogspot.com/2011/01/musing-mondays.html
Good question, Miz B! My reading tends to go in stages, but here’s the stage I’m in now:
http://laurelrainsnow.wordpress.com/2011/01/17/musing-mondays-meaty-or-fluffy-jan-17/
Great question! My answers are here!
I read both but probably most often fall into the middle as well.
Here’s my musings on today’s topic.
Hi Miz B! I love your blog! Here is my first Musing Mondays post:
http://booksdownsouth.wordpress.com/2011/01/17/she-returns-with-musing-mondays/
Thank you!
Lost Christianities does sounds interesting! Glad you are enjoying it!
Here’s my post for today.
http://amongstories.wordpress.com/2011/01/17/mm-what-you-read/
I look at it this way: should be literature and not just any fiction. Full musing is up.
My reading tends to be 60/40 in favor of nonfiction — mostly history, science, or philosophy. I like a book with a lot of meat on it, and that goes for novels as well. The lightest reading I do is Star Trek paperbacks, and those have been increasingly substantial in recent years.
Gotta say I’m mostly a fluff girl with a little bit of “lean” meat thrown in
Here’s my post.
Aww — that’s so poetic and sad — “or was it only the rain?” Why is she crying?
Here’s my teaser from Delirium by Lauren Oliver
Sorry! I clicked the wrong comments link, apparently!
Here is mine!
http://frosybookreviews.blogspot.com/2011/01/teaser-tuesday-4.html
wrong post opps!!! Oh well… at least I found out more blogs!
I really really really want to read this!
Reply